Russia reiventing the Wheel/Governance is not always better governance

Sir, Russia"s President Dimitry Medvedev has recently proposed a new global charter on international energy co-operation. This comes on the heels of the most recent Russian/Ukrainian gas dispute that left Europe with significantly reduced supplies of gas in the first days of January this year. This was by far the worst disruption of Russian gas supplies ever to Europe, and it has reinforced European concern that it is overly dependant on Russian gas and insufficiently prepared for prolonged gas supply disruptions whatever their origins. Reactions to the disruption were sharp and Russia"s long-standing reputation as a reliable supplier of natural gas was deeply sullied. It is impossible to sort through the gas market/commercial/political origins of this conflict from simmering geopolitics related to Ukraine"s flirtations with NATO or missile defense systems in Russia"s backyard to internecine warfare among Ukraine"s political “leadership”. Intermingled throughout were those who extract rents from the opaque trading relationships between the declared and undeclared gas market players. President Medvedev has taken the trouble to come up with yet another set of principles Russia would like to see apply in global or at least Eurasian energy markets - but as he makes clear himself, he needn"t have bothered. Even if the Charter has not lived up to Russia"s expectations, its principles remain sound. Furthermore, the G8 spent considerable time regrouping most of the Charter"s principles, along with materials from the collapsed MAI negotiations (1998) at the OECD to develop the St Petersburg Global Energy Security Principles released by the G8 at the Russian-hosted Summit in July 2006. At last year"s G8 Summit in Hokkaido, each of the G8 countries self-assessed their compliance with the St Petersburg Principles. The results of that self appraisal were not made public. Why not just return to those principles so carefully negotiated, rather than undertake yet another process that can only delay practical implementation. Conduct another more systematic and public appraisal of G8 countries" adherence to these agreed principles and allow actual national policies and practices to be evaluated in the court of public opinion. Of course the court of public opinion will take an interest in Russia"s own policies and practices as a transit state for Central Asian oil & gas.
Available in:
Regions and themes
Share
Related centers and programs
Discover our other research centers and programsFind out more
Discover all our analysesAI, Data Centers and Energy Demand: Reassessing and Exploring the Trends
The information and communication technologies sector today accounts for 9% of global electricity consumption, data centers for 1-1.3%, and artificial intelligence (AI) for less than 0.2%. The growing energy demands of cloud services first, and now AI workloads (10% of today’s data centers electricity demand), have exacerbated this trend. In the future, hyperscale data centers will gain shares amongst all kinds of data centers and AI will probably account for around 20% of data centers electricity demand by 2030.
Unlocking India’s Energy Transition: Addressing Grid Flexibility Challenges and Solutions
India is rapidly scaling up its renewable energy (RE) capacity, adding 15–20 GW annually, but the ambitious goal of 500 GW of non-fossil capacity by 2030 is at risk unless the pace accelerates.
Europe’s Black Mass Evasion: From Black Box to Strategic Recycling
EV batteries recycling is a building block for boosting the European Union (EU)’s strategic autonomy in the field of critical raw minerals (CRM) value chains. Yet, recent evolutions in the European EV value chain, marked by cancellations or postponements of projects, are raising the alarm on the prospects of the battery recycling industry in Europe.

The New Geopolitics of Energy
Following the dramatic floods in Valencia, and as COP29 opens in Baku, climate change is forcing us to closely reexamine the pace—and the stumbling blocks—of the energy transition.